Author: Kip Lytel, CFA I Founder, Montecito Capital Management
Having spent my career analyzing financial markets, managing investment portfolios and navigating multiple market cycles, I have learned that some of the most important investment decisions are made during periods of heightened uncertainty—not when markets are rising comfortably. Today’s sharp selloff deserves attention, but it also requires perspective. At Montecito Capital Management, we look beyond daily headlines and market reactions, combining fundamental research, historical market analysis, quantitative modeling and disciplined portfolio construction to distinguish between short-term volatility and meaningful changes in the market’s underlying direction. I want to share our assessment of what happened, what our RegimeSignal™ market model is telling us, what the fundamentals reveal, and—most importantly—how our clients’ portfolios navigated today’s volatility.
WHAT HAPPENED IN THE MARKET
Stocks suffered a particularly difficult session. The S&P 500 fell 4.4%, the Nasdaq dropped 5.5%, the Nasdaq 100 declined 6.4%, and the Dow lost 3.4%. Today’s losses erased Wednesday’s post-midterm rally, when the Dow recorded its strongest post-midterm election gain since 1982. For the week, the S&P 500 is down approximately 3%, the Nasdaq 4.4%, and the Dow remains nearly flat.
The selling was especially concentrated in AI and semiconductor stocks. The semiconductor index fell approximately 11%, wiping out roughly $2 trillion in chip-stock market value in a single session. Meanwhile, the VIX, Wall Street’s primary fear gauge, surged approximately 70%, its largest one-day increase in more than two years. Today’s selling reflects more than routine profit-taking. Investors are reassessing the extraordinary expectations embedded in AI-related stocks, while concerns about the pace of data-center investment and the sustainability of valuations have added pressure.
Nevertheless, a sharp decline in even some of the market’s largest companies does not automatically signal a broader economic or market breakdown.
HOW OUR CLIENTS’ PORTFOLIOS HELD UP
Across the combined client assets we manage, portfolios declined approximately 1.49% today, compared with 4.4% for the S&P 500 and 5.5% for the Nasdaq. That means the aggregate decline in our managed assets was approximately one-third of the S&P 500’s decline and about one-quarter of the Nasdaq’s.
That difference is precisely why we believe diversification across asset classes and investment strategies matters—particularly when markets become disorderly.
While technology and semiconductor stocks experienced significant losses, many of our holdings moved the other way:
- Alternative strategies helped offset equity-market weakness, with several positions holding up or advancing. One of our alternative funds gained 4.6% on the day.
- Precious metals contributed positively, with our gold holdings up 1.7%.
- Investment-grade bonds finished largely in the green, and Treasuries benefited from falling yields, which generally support bond prices.
- Utility equities we own advanced, adding defensive balance within the equity sleeve.
- Buffered investments provided an additional layer of downside protection.
This is a practical example of how portfolio construction can help manage downside exposure. Our objective is not simply to participate when markets rise, but to build portfolios that can withstand difficult markets without forcing clients to abandon their long-term investment plans.
WHAT OUR MARKET MODEL IS TELLING US
Our proprietary RegimeSignal™ market model is built to predict the turns across the entire S&P 500 market cycle: bull markets, pullbacks, corrections, bear markets and recoveries. Across its four market signals, it has averaged 84% prediction accuracy when a signal fires. The model has been PhD-validated and independently audited. Despite today’s volatility, RegimeSignal™ continues to identify the overall market environment as Bull.
Importantly, none of our four market signals—Bear, Correction, Pullback or Recovery—is currently active. Bull Health currently stands at 74 on our 0–90 scale, with 75 representing a typical healthy bull market.
We did become more cautious on October 18, downgrading the market from Bull Strengthening to Bull Steady. That distinction matters. We recognized that momentum was moderating and adjusted our assessment accordingly, without prematurely declaring a bear market. The market remains a bull market, and a steady one.
Today’s decline has not, by itself, changed that assessment.
We pay particular attention to changes in market behavior, not simply the magnitude of a single day’s decline. A sustained deterioration in our signals would be a different matter, and we would respond accordingly.
This is the value of having a systematic process: rather than reacting to headlines or attempting to predict every market move, we evaluate whether the underlying market environment is actually changing.
IS THE SELLING JUSTIFIED? LOOK BENEATH THE SURFACE.
There is a legitimate reason for some of the selling. Several AI-related and semiconductor stocks had advanced substantially faster than their underlying earnings, creating crowded positions and elevated expectations. A valuation reset in those companies is not necessarily unhealthy. The correction beneath the market’s surface has been considerably more extensive than the headline index suggests.
Approximately 69% of S&P 500 technology stocks are trading at least 20% below their respective 52-week highs. Yet the S&P 500 itself remains only approximately 6% below its October 6 record. That tells us something important: much of the damage has been concentrated in particular sectors and individual stocks rather than distributed evenly across the market.
We also examined historical periods when the market experienced comparable one-day declines near record highs. Since 1928, there have been 20 instances in which the S&P 500 declined at least 3.5% in a single session while trading near its highs.
The subsequent results are worth noting:
- Three months later: The market was higher in 15 of 20 instances, with a typical gain of approximately 6%.
- Six months later: The market was higher in 17 of 20 instances, with a typical gain of approximately 9%.
These observations do not guarantee a recovery or tell us exactly when to buy. They do, however, demonstrate why reacting emotionally to a single severe market decline has historically been a poor substitute for evaluating the broader trend and underlying fundamentals.
WHERE WE ARE IN THE CURRENT BULL MARKET
The current bull market began October 12, 2022. It is now just over four years old, with the S&P 500 having advanced approximately 106% since its beginning. Historically, since the 1940s, the average bull market has lasted approximately four and a half years and generated gains of roughly 155%.
By historical standards, this bull market is mature, but its age alone does not establish that it is nearing an end. Bull markets do not operate on a fixed timetable. We look to market behavior, economic conditions and our model’s signals to assess whether the trend remains intact.
EARNINGS, VALUATIONS AND THE ECONOMIC BACKDROP
One of the most important reasons we are not interpreting this selloff as an economic breakdown is that both the earnings and the macroeconomic backdrop remain positive.
Corporate earnings
According to FactSet’s latest earnings updates:
- Earnings growth: Third-quarter S&P 500 earnings are growing approximately 30% year over year.
- Revenue growth: Revenue is growing approximately 13%, indicating that earnings strength is supported by actual business growth.
- Earnings surprises: Approximately 82% of reporting companies have exceeded earnings estimates.
- Full-year outlook: Analysts are projecting approximately 33% earnings growth for calendar year 2026.
Perhaps most importantly, earnings growth is broadening beyond the largest technology companies.
The Magnificent Seven grew third-quarter earnings approximately 33%, while the other 493 S&P 500 companies grew approximately 28%. For the fourth quarter, analysts expect the broader 493 to grow faster than the Magnificent Seven, approximately 31% versus 24%.
This is a significant development. It suggests corporate earnings strength is becoming more widely distributed across the market rather than depending primarily on a handful of mega-cap technology companies.
Market valuations
Before this week’s selloff, the S&P 500 traded at approximately 18.7 times forward earnings, already below its five-year average of 19.8 and its ten-year average of 19.1. With stock prices declining while earnings expectations remain strong, valuations have become more attractive.
This is an important distinction: falling prices accompanied by deteriorating earnings expectations present a different investment environment than falling prices against a backdrop of strong corporate profitability.
The macroeconomic backdrop
The broader economic picture remains positive. Unemployment claims and layoffs remain low; October job cuts were the lowest since 2023. Credit markets are functioning normally: the extra yield investors demand to hold high-yield corporate bonds is close to its long-term norm, which tells us the bond market is not pricing in economic stress. Credit markets have historically been an early warning of real trouble, and today they are not sounding one.
Market confidence
Our Market Confidence Index, which measures how fully investors are actually committed to the market, stands at 71 on a 0–100 scale, where 50 is typical. Household equity allocations and margin borrowing remain near record levels. Consumer sentiment, by contrast, is near historic lows.
That combination tells us something useful. People feel worried, but their money remains invested. Investors are not abandoning the market—they are nervous within it. Confidence measured by where money sits is a more reliable read than confidence measured by surveys. High investor commitment can make individual days like today sharper, but it is not the profile of a market in which investors are heading for the exits. Taken together, we view the current selling as a significant market correction concentrated in an overextended area of the equity market—not yet evidence of a fundamental economic deterioration.
INFLATION AND THE FEDERAL RESERVE
Inflation remains an important risk, but the composition of inflation matters. Headline inflation is approximately 3.7%, while core inflation is 2.6%. Much of the difference is attributable to energy, with gasoline accounting for more than half of September’s price increase. This is important because energy-driven inflation is different from inflation caused by an overheating domestic economy.
The conflict with Iran and its impact on oil prices have introduced additional inflationary pressure that monetary policy cannot directly resolve.
The Federal Reserve raised interest rates in September. To its credit, the FOMC had the foresight to hold rates steady at its most recent meeting in late October, recognizing that much of today’s inflation is energy-driven rather than the product of an overheating economy. The next decision comes at the Fed’s December meeting, and markets currently anticipate another increase. We believe additional tightening under these circumstances would be counterproductive. Between now and then, the October inflation report on November 10, the direction of oil prices, and any progress toward a resolution with Iran will shape that decision.
Higher interest rates cannot increase oil production or resolve geopolitical conflicts. They can, however, restrict credit, slow business investment and put additional pressure on otherwise healthy areas of the economy. If energy prices moderate or geopolitical tensions ease, that would remove an important headwind for both inflation and equity markets.
We will continue monitoring energy prices, inflation and Federal Reserve policy for any changes that could materially affect the market outlook.
THE MIDTERM ELECTIONS AND WHAT HISTORY SUGGESTS
The Democrats won control of both the House and Senate on Tuesday. While the political implications are significant, our research covering 98 years of market history has found no reliable relationship between which party controls Congress and subsequent stock-market performance.
We would therefore avoid making investment decisions based on the election outcome itself.
There are, however, two historical seasonal patterns worth watching as we approach the next calendar year.
- The presidential cycle: The first half of a president’s third year has historically been one of the stronger periods of the four-year presidential cycle. Historically, this period has also tended to be favorable when the incumbent president cannot run for reelection.
- December seasonality: December has historically been one of the most consistently positive months of the year, producing positive returns approximately 72% of the time since 1928. November through April has also historically been the stronger six-month period for equities.
Seasonality is not a forecast, but it provides useful historical context when considered alongside earnings, valuations and market trends.
HOW YOUR PORTFOLIO IS POSITIONED FOR MARKETS LIKE THIS
Today’s relative performance illustrates why we believe a diversified, multi-asset, multi-strategy approach is important.
For most of our clients, more than 30% of portfolio assets are allocated to alternative investments. Beyond alternatives, our portfolios incorporate a broad range of investments, including:
- Alternative strategies: Hedged equity, long-short strategies, managed futures and other investments designed to provide different sources of return.
- Equities and specialized ETFs: Individual stocks and carefully selected equity ETFs, including strategies emphasizing high-quality companies, lower volatility and other fundamental characteristics.
- Domestic and international bonds: Fixed-income investments providing income and diversification across different markets and interest-rate environments.
- Buffered ETFs: Investments designed to absorb a defined portion of market losses, subject to their specific terms and limitations.
- Precious metals and commodities: Exposures that can provide additional diversification and potential protection against certain inflationary and geopolitical risks.
- Real estate investment trusts (REITs): Additional exposure to income-producing real estate outside traditional stock and bond markets.
The important distinction is that we are not simply diversifying by owning more investments. We are combining different asset classes and investment strategies with different risk characteristics and sources of return. No individual investment or strategy is expected to protect against every market decline. Together, however, these exposures help reduce dependence on any single market outcome and improve the overall resilience of a portfolio.
Our objective is to capture meaningful market upside while managing downside exposure. Today’s results demonstrate the potential value of that approach.
WHAT HAPPENS NEXT
As of this evening, S&P 500 futures are trading at 7,342, down about 0.6%, pointing to a softer open tomorrow. Futures trade overnight, however, and that picture can change quickly before the open, particularly with Friday’s employment report ahead. We are not making wholesale portfolio changes in reaction to one difficult trading session. Given how resilient most of our clients’ portfolios were through today’s upheaval, that is one silver lining of a difficult day: it confirmed that our portfolios are built to absorb this kind of shock.
Our decisions will continue to be driven by changes in market conditions, underlying fundamentals and the signals generated by RegimeSignal™. If those indicators materially change, we will respond and communicate that to you. Markets can be uncomfortable, particularly when volatility increases this quickly. But it is precisely during these periods that experience, disciplined portfolio management and a clearly defined investment process matter most.